Sediment-stressed reefs over the past 420 Myr

Worldwide, reefs are under significant pressure, and hence, understanding the consequences of natural and anthropogenically driven sediment influx to reef systems is crucial to planning future protection strategies. Most reef systems are associated with clear water settings, but reefs also evolved in turbid water environments stressed by high rates of sediment influx. Mixed carbonate–clastic environments have been considered unfavourable to reef-building organisms. Currently, we lack generally applicable models for (i) reef growth under the stress of siliciclastic sediment influx and (ii) tools that diagnose ancient reefs that developed in sediment-stressed environments. Case studies of sediment-stressed reefs from the Devonian to the recent reviewed here demonstrate that reef organisms show the ability to survive, and even thrive, under clastic sediment influx. These case studies were selected based on (i) the presence of a mixed carbonate-clastic matrix and (ii) the existence of a coral framework. For each example, the system was characterised in terms of sediment input, organism growth forms and the overall reef architecture. The host sediment from Cenozoic reefs is typically better described than that within Palaeozoic and Mesozoic communities. This may be due to the closer affinity between Cenozoic communities and recent species compared to more ancient systems. The same reasoning accounts for the paucity of data describing the internal structure of many fossil reefs, a feature also related to outcrop quality. Moreover, the juxtaposition of siliciclastic interbeds and ancient reefal bodies should not be taken as conclusive evidence that clastic influx was contemporaneous with the active growth stages of the framework organisms. Based on the data reviewed here, no relationship was identified between the nature of the reef builders, the character of the siliciclastic component and the reef structure. We suggest that this lack of understanding of mixed carbonate-clastic reef systems significantly compromises potential forecasts of future reef development.