CPU vs. GPU - Performance comparison for the Gram-Schmidt algorithm
The Gram-Schmidt method is a classical method for determining QR decompositions, which is commonly used in many applications in computational physics, such as orthogonalization of quantum mechanical operators or Lyapunov stability analysis. In this paper, we discuss how well the Gram-Schmidt method performs on different hardware architectures, including both state-of-the-art GPUs and CPUs. We explain, in detail, how a smart interplay between hardware and software can be used to speed up those rather compute intensive applications as well as the benefits and disadvantages of several approaches. In addition, we compare some highly optimized standard routines of the BLAS libraries against our own optimized routines on both processor types. Particular attention was paid to the strong hierarchical memory of modern GPUs and CPUs, which requires cache-aware blocking techniques for optimal performance. Our investigations show that the performance strongly depends on the employed algorithm, compiler and a little less on the employed hardware. Remarkably, the performance of the NVIDIA CUDA BLAS routines improved significantly from CUDA 3.2 to CUDA 4.0. Still, BLAS routines tend to be slightly slower than manually optimized code on GPUs, while we were not able to outperform the BLAS routines on CPUs. Comparing optimized implementations on different hardware architectures, we find that a NVIDIA GeForce GTX580 GPU is about 50% faster than a corresponding Intel X5650 Westmere hexacore CPU. The self-written codes are included as supplementary material.
Institute for Computational Physics, University of Stuttgart, Pfaffenwaldring 27, 70569, Stuttgart, Germany