Lagrangian approach for stratospheric aerosol and gas experiment (SAGE) II profile intercomparisons

Trajectory calculations are employed to identify Stratospheric Aerosol and Gas Experiment (SAGE) II flights sampling the same air mass as is observed by a groundbased aerosol lidar at Garmisch-Partenkirchen, Germany (47.5°N, 11.1°E, 735 m above sea level), during the periods of January-April 1993 and January-December 1998. Intercomparisons between lidar-observed and SAGE II-derived backscatters at 532 nm are conducted. Percentage differences between trajectory-tracked SAGE II profiles and ground-based lidar observations with respect to aerosol lidar are generally within 20 - 40 %, though localized discrepancies > 50 % are found for some cases. In addition, aerosol extinction, aerosol to molecular extinction ratio, and ozone mixing ratio profiles obtained from the SAGE II flights overpassing the vicinity of Garmisch-Partenkirchen during the January-April 1993 period are compared with profiles obtained from corresponding trajectory-tracked SAGE II flights. Percentage discrepancies between SAGE II ozone profiles are generally within 10 - 20 % above the Junge layer. Data comparisons for aerosol profiles show mixed results. While some cases agree within the error bars, there are several cases where percentage discrepancies exceed 50 %.