A staged approach using ants as test organism in ecotoxicology

Although ants (Hymenoptera: Formicidae) are ecological key components, they are currently not included in ecotoxicity testing. Based on their social organization, ecology and exposure routes to pesticides, we propose a multilevel testing scheme for ants starting from isolated workers (level-1), workers and brood (level-2) and founding queens or entire colonies (level-3). To evaluate feasibility, we tested three ant species (Camponotus maculatus, Crematogaster sp., Lasius niger) using the neonicotinoid imidacloprid as a test substance. Ants were orally exposed through liquid food.
At level-1, worker survival showed a clear concentration response and allowed to estimate LC50 with sufficiently narrow confidence intervals. In level-2, worker mortality and sublethal effects negatively affected larval survival and development, e.g. occurrence of naked pupae, with a lower NOEC for larvae (<0.05 mg/L feeding solution) than for workers (1.7 mg/L). At level-3, the test substance significantly reduced the reproductive output of newly mated L. niger queens over 21 days after a single exposure to 0.5 mg/L.
Our results confirm that ants can be easily handled and tested in the laboratory, making them a valuable extension for ecotoxicity testing. Given their ecological relevance, easy culture in laboratory settings and promising first results, we recommend further research using our new testing scheme, e.g. testing other stressors, species and endpoints. Establishing a robust test protocol for ants would provide coverage of a new and ecologically important group of non-target insects, which contributes to a broader protection of biodiversity and ecosystems.