Performance Comparison of Multipixel Biaxial Scanning Direct Time-of-Flight Light Detection and Ranging Systems With and Without Imaging Optics

The laser pulse detection probability of a scanning direct time-of-flight light detection and ranging (LiDAR) measurement is evaluated based on the optical signal distribution on a multipixel single photon avalanche diode (SPAD) array. These detectors intrinsically suffer from dead-times after the successful detection of a single photon and, thus, allow only for limited counting statistics when multiple returning laser photons are imaged on a single pixel. By blurring the imaged laser spot, the transition from single-pixel statistics with high signal intensity to multipixel statistics with less signal intensity is examined. Specifically, a comparison is made between the boundary cases in which (i) the returning LiDAR signal is focused through optics onto a single pixel and (ii) the detection is performed without lenses using all available pixels on the sensor matrix. The omission of imaging optics reduces the overall system size and minimizes optical transfer losses, which is crucial given the limited laser emission power due to safety standards. The investigation relies on a photon rate model for interfering (background) and signal light, applied to a simulated first-photon sensor architecture. For single-shot scenarios that reflect the optimal use of the time budget in scanning LiDAR systems, the lens-less and blurred approaches can achieve comparable or even superior results to the focusing system. This highlights the potential of fully solid-state scanning LiDAR systems utilizing optical phase arrays or multidirectional laser chips.