Options
2026
Journal Article
Title
Trust Without Access Does Not Sell: Distribution-Driven Refurbished Smartphone Adoption in Germany and Belgium
Abstract
Increasing the market share of refurbished smartphones is critical to promoting sustainable consumption and advancing circular economy objectives, yet consumer uptake remains constrained by perceived risk (PR, or consumers’ perceived uncertainty regarding the potential negative consequences of purchasing refurbished smartphones). This study addresses a gap in the literature by examining how risk perception, trust signals, and perceived distribution intensity (PDI, or the extent to which consumers view a product as widely available) jointly shape purchase intention (PI, or consumers’ willingness or likelihood to purchase) in refurbished smartphone markets. Using survey data collected in Fall 2025 from 600 adult smartphone users in Germany and Belgium, we employ multi-group structural equation modeling to test direct, indirect, and sequential effects, as well as cross-national invariance. The results show that as PR, price consciousness (PC, or the extent to which consumers focus on price when evaluating a purchase), and reliance on seller reputation (SR, or the extent to which consumers rely on the seller’s reputation when evaluating a purchase) increase. While SR positively influences perceptions of distribution quality, it exhibits a negative direct effect on PI in both countries. PDI, or how available a product seems to consumers, emerges as the strongest and most consistent predictor of PI, indicating that trust alone is insufficient to motivate adoption unless accessible and reliable distribution systems support it. Analyses further reveal that PDI fully mediates the relationship between SR and PI, and sequentially, distribution also mediates the effect of PR and SR. These mechanisms are largely invariant across Germany and Belgium. The findings suggest that firms should shift emphasis from reputation-building alone toward investing in PDI-related safeguards, such as transparent return policies, warranty enforcement, and after-sales service infrastructure. For policymakers, the results highlight the importance of strengthening institution-based consumer protections and distributional access to enable circular consumption. The study demonstrates that in refurbished smartphone markets, trust must be operationalized through credible PDI structures to translate sustainability intentions into actual purchasing behavior.
Author(s)